All time HD/Ticket HD

Ok well here is my suggestion:
So, we have are already HD that should take a Ticket.
Shaman:
200,000 EXP, 15,000 Points, 2 Enhancement Stones, 30 Gems Not sure Spawn Rate
Now the CI/SI Exp should be 3-5x more then they are now. 4x IMO

And then All Time HD,
Shaman:
50,000 Exp, 3750 Points, 1 Enhancement Stone, 7 Gems, Lesser Respawn Rate
CI/SI Normal Exp Like Co Op Servers.

 

People level up too fast in Helms Deep, and we have the problem with slots, people who spend 10 hours in there and don't leave for a minute (and doesn't know sun light).

I don't think Marvel will bring it back (again) and make it permanent. If he will, no awards for Shaman would be a good idea, since the Charity skill gives you tons of exp even if do nothing.

 

I don't mind HD as it's something different from coop and VS and i agree with haze that shaman's reward should be turned off and that should solve the problem.

 

Not turned off, rather decreased a lot, like stated in the OP. Or, have much more stronger tanks, like knight tanks appear. Maybe even hell tanks.

 

Compairing Extreme servers with Helms Deep, the second map spawns way more tanks, so the chances to a Shaman appears is high.

Why people go to Helms Deep? To kill Shaman. Why people wants to kill it? Because of the awards. Then we will have a 16/16 server running all time.

Helms Deep is a farming map for itself, you just need to throw a molotov in the right places to get 30-50% of exp in a single round. With the Shaman award you complete the others 70-50% exp. Reducing the award will still make people obsessed with the Shaman tank.

No awards. You will still get a lot of exp and points. Be happy with it.

 

All time HD - less shaman spawn chance, no buy menu, no crawl

Ticket based HD - normal spawn chance, buy menu, crawl